"Let's be friends."
Those are the most ludicrous words after a break-up.
It's not that I think men and women can't be friends. I have lots of male friends, running the gamut from casual to intimate. (Poor Hammer knows waaaay more than he'd probably like to know.) While I do tend to gravitate toward women for those very close friendships, there are and have been a few exceptions over the years.
Even within the bounds of Stephanie-Dude friendships, sometimes the lines have become blurred by deep emotional or spiritual connection. Sometimes by both. If there's also a sexual attraction, the relationship can become complicated rather quickly. Sometimes I've been able to pull back from that and maintain the platonic relationship. Sometimes not.)
Usually what happens, though, is that I go through this experience with whatever man, and the relationship is damaged by sex and love and what has most often felt like compromise that was unevenly anchored to my side. Hot Pocket would toss in the words "unevenly yoked" right here. Moonshine might suggest something about unbalanced equations. My therapist would kindly and gently advise me to determine what I'm willing to accept to maintain a healthy relationship and where I can confidently draw my lines—with the mindful acceptance that I must defend those boundaries if push comes to shove.
Bounder and I went back and forth for days that turned into weeks about how and where our relationship was going. He says he's not an alcoholic; I still question it openly and to his face. Almost regardless of that, there's still the issue of my caring about him. He is special to me. Tierney says it best, to Alex, during one of their last conversations in Persona Non Grata:
"Look, I don't love a lot of people. I don't like a lot of people, and all these people in my life have really hurt me over the years. I have reasons to be wary of letting people in. When I do, and especially when I choose to let them in far enough to love them, they're special. You are a very rare breed of human being that I both like and love, and not just because I have to. That's why I get so mad about it all. That's why it feels so unfair. I don't want that to have been a waste of my energy."
Part of the issue for me is this idea of being compartmentalized, of feeling like I'm being shoved and cajoled into a box that keeps me away from the other person. Yes, it is something men tend to do more than women; it seems to be an innate coping mechanism for them. Again, Alex and Tierney discuss this early on in their relationship:
[Alex Wheeler] "That's how I am; if someone makes me mad or bothers me too much, I'll just ignore them—won't answer their calls or texts or emails. I'll just stop."
"Are you that way with everything? Do you just ignore what you don't like?"
He thought about it for a moment. "Yeah. I compartmentalize everything. I have to, in some ways, being on the road all the time. It helps keep me sane. I'm really good at keeping everything in its own neat, little box, where I can deal with it or not, as I choose. I'm probably too good at it."
"I think that's a guy thing," I commented. He nodded in agreement. "I think it's much harder for women to take their feelings out of the equation. Men are much better at tucking their feelings out of the way."
When a relationship is ending for whatever reason, what do you do after you've been through an intense period of time with this person whom you both like and love (on whatever level), with whom you've shared deep intimacies, and without whom you feel a little lost?
While I still occasionally have very platonic contact with Absolem, he was always an exception to the rule—though that was no real surprise given the nature of our relationship. I know damn well that I will always have that tie to him, that weird connection that brought him in and out of my life as a catalyst to upend me and bring about my own transformation. I owe him so much, and I owe him nothing. But I know that even if I weren't to hear from him for twenty years, he would know within moments of making contact exactly how and where I was in my head and my heart and my soul. We are, in so many ways, two sides of the same coin.
I made the break, privately and publicly, from Bounder, but he didn't disappear. It was confusing. It started with the careful arguing and the constant discussing of what this relationship had meant and was supposed to mean and how impactful it was for each of us and why, along with where and when what went wrong—like an emotional debriefing with the only other person who could truly understand it because they'd lived it with me. The inner circle was great about listening and advising and letting me cry when I needed to do so, but ultimately the answers and solutions would only come from me and from Bounder.
Our relationship could stop or move
forward in myriad ways. We could take
the leap of faith and delve into this and see what happened. We could agree to part ways for some period
of time and plan to meet back up, if the time was right. We could date slowly for a while and move
along at a more reasonable pace, ignoring everything that had pushed us
together in the first place. Or we could
just say our goodbyes and be done.
Eventually it was plain that we were tired, dancing wide, serpentining lines around this place and time that wasn't yet right for us. No matter how drawn we were and are to each other, here and now wasn't going be ours. Not like this. And the seeming pressure of divine intervention felt yet again like Fate had played a cruel trick, taunting me with, "Oh? You want this? Too damn bad! You can't have it!"
So, again, I told him no, that I can't do this, that I can't watch him from some nebulous place of distant care and be flirty witness to his life. I am worth more than that; at least on this we agree. I told him to find me if and when he was ready to accept the whole of my affections and to reciprocate healthily in kind. I wished him well.
"You haven't given me a chance to tell you what I want out of this right now," he patiently stated when he called.
Well, I've given you plenty of opportunity. It's not my fault you've refused to take it when it was offered.
"So what is that you want?" I asked, feeling a little defiant underneath it all.
"I want you to be you, and I want to be your friend. I want to still see you and talk to you and blahblahblah."
"So you still want me in your life and want to maintain that connection with me? But you can't commit emotionally, no matter how badly you say you want to be able to? And maybe you want to have sex with me, if it feels like the right thing to do?"
"Yes."
What the fuck?
The truth is I don't want him gone from my life. He is sweet and funny and smart. He knows me incredibly well and has seen through my facade of bravado from the moment we met. Even though he is often willing to grant me the freedom to maintain that glittery face, he also doesn't hesitate to call bullshit on it and on me. He's one of very few people (especially men) who call tell me no. I want a healthy relationship with him. I care deeply for him, and he has impacted me in ways very few men, or people in general, have been able to do. But I also don't want to spiral back into the dark place of striving for attention, of flustering for a fleeting moment of care and affection.
I don't want to be told no just because he has the power to do so; sometimes I get to be right.
And as
Tierney sums up later:
Alex had kept me in a box, but within those confines I could expose myself totally, free to explore the ever-expanding boundaries of my soul without fear of judgment. If he couldn't handle what he saw, all he had to do was close the box. It was how he handled his own soul.
To ask this of me, to negotiate platonic friendship with the possibility of an eventual more, is unquestionably an effort to compartmentalize me and our relationship. I understand that the fragility of this cat is undercut by recent and deep trauma, that he could very well crack at any time. It's a defense mechanism, undoubtedly, and he has every right and reason to seek that comfort in his world in the hopes that he can heal from what came before me.
I have every right and reason to say no.
I'm not going back in the box.
Having lived the life that brought
me to this version of Stephanie, I am very wary and sensitive to that kind of
one-sided consideration. I was left on
my own for years, emotionally, and
tend to gravitate toward people (again, especially men) who are selective in
their attentions. Whether their reasons
are emotional or logistical in nature serves only to explain the behavior; there
are reasons but no excuses.
Because of my sensitivity to feeling dismissed or ignored, I will never not respond to the boxers. I cannot ignore their calls to attention. I know precisely how that hurts and loathe the feeling so much that I would never wish it on anyone I care about.
I will always be his friend, but right now I don't know that I can be just his friend. I want and am ready to be special to someone else (though I am not actively seeking anyone to fill that role), and we both thought at first that he was ready for that, as well—that we were both ready to be special to each other. But intention and fruition don't always fall in line with each other; no matter how much it looked like this was supposed to be here and now, that's simply not how it's working, even though I question his direct role in that creating and maintaining that obstacle.
The thought that I could go through this with him, that yet again I could meet someone who could alter my own path so dramatically, and that he won't be at the end of this leg of the journey with me is simply terrifying. Right now, while I care about him so deeply and want him to be healthy and content in himself, the risk of seeing him fall for someone else when he's finally ready to crack his own facade for another person... it's just too much. Maybe it's not me, and it is him, as he's said so roundabout, but it's still me that faces the greatest possibility of being hurt again. To keep me in his web of care means that I will feel the vibrations of secondary movement. It could be him shifting slowly toward me, or it could be him scurrying in another direction. Either way, it leaves me stuck and slowed by his gossamer threads, grappling at my feet.
But to turn away from him leaves my friend in need.
I don't know where this is going any more now than I did when it started. The good part is that it has given me an opportunity to understand and accept that, no matter how much influence I may or may not be able to exert on a force, sometimes the situation simply isn't mine to control.
So for a little while longer, he and I are in this weird, nebulous state of... what? Friends? Not friends? Not lovers? I don't know, and I'm honestly tired of not thinking and thinking and overthinking. I will do what I do, be who I am, and whatever comes from that is what will be. While I won't attempt to unduly influence the outcome of this situation, I'm also not sitting passively by, waiting for Bounder to take me out of the shiny box and play with me.